Went there in the late afternoon for lunch & had a GREAT waiter, Nick. At the table was a Walleye Po Boy sandwich & a chicken salad. Both pretty good. Nick was the best: bottomless coffee & very attentive. The dessert was not so great, new vendor, Costco has better stuff. The green beans were marvelous, a certain surprise.
Went back the next night & others had ordered the green beans, based on my recommendation: I could tell at a glance that they wouldn't be as good as the previous afternoon, and they weren't. Shared pretzels & had the Mac & Cheese with Shrimp. The Mac & Cheese needs work, still better than most, yet not as good as Martha Stewart's: http://www.marthastewart.com/271998/perfect-macaroni-and-cheese
To sum it up: the first day they weren't busy & we got lots of attention, good food and a great waiter., The second time was at night, they were v. busy & the food wasn't as good as the first lunch, but still, much better than many of the local places.
Willoughby Brewing, we'll come back, but please work on your evening game!