More like 3.5 stars. Everything sounded great, but did not meet our expectations. Pimento fondue app was good, but nothing special. I think the crostini overpowered the dip. I had the meatloaf. It was a little dry and bland. The sides (collards and mushroom risotto) were great, though. I think the risotto is one of the best I ever had...so creamy. My husband had the shrimp and grits and thought it was good. Overall, a good meal.