On the whole, the pizzas are good. Yeah, for $5 and change, they're good.
I see some reviewers were critical of the store for not having pizza ready when they get in. It's happened to me a couple of times, and yes, it's kind of annoying. At five bucks, I won't complain. You can order a pizza in advance if you'd like.
The salads, however, are priced kind of high, and a couple of times I ended up with wilted, slimy, and or brown lettuce (the owner or employees just trying to increase the shelf life and minimize waste). If you get a fresh salad, they're worth it. If you don't--right in the trash. I've gotten a bad salad too many times to want to gamble on them anymore. Pizza is still good though.
PS--some of the people working there are sharp and on the ball, but some of the HS kids seem pretty out of it. The service they provide is fine--they just seem disinterested, lethargic, and mellow (a little too mellow sometimes or maybe everyone in HS is like that). Going back to what I noted earlier...the pizza is just five bucks, so I won't complain :)