I've been here once for drinks and once for dinner. The cocktails are fantastic - great combos made from fresh ingredients. They aren't cheap, but you get what you pay for.
When we came for dinner at 7 on a Friday night, we waited at the bar for maybe 20 minutes. I thought that was reasonable. A lot of things on the menu looked good. We started with a cheese plate, then I had wheat berry salad and greens with a bacon dressing. I had originally ordered a kale salad that they were out of. Kind of annoying but I assume they are using just the fresh ingredients they can procure that day/week, so I'm ok with it. I really enjoyed both of my selections. We also had a great red wine.
As far as negatives, they do need to do something about the entryway and the drafts. Wisconsin winter are way too cold. Also, it's not cheap, but I think the prices are fair.