I find myself going back to Tommy's time and time again because the food is so great! I love to take friends from out-of-town here to show them a great and inexpensive establishment. The menu is very long, so it usually takes me several minutes of reading and narrowing down to figure out what I want to eat! I have honestly never had anything that I haven't liked here. Although I'm not a vegetarian, I prefer of the meat-free options here, like the Tofu salad sandwich (which tastes incredibly like an egg-salad sandwich!) and the Quinn, which is a cheese and peanut butter sandwich (I know, it sounds like it shouldn't work, but it definitely does!).
When you come here, you absolutely have to try the milkshakes! They are fantastic, dare I say the best in Cleveland? You can mix more than one flavor, or add different toppings into your shake to make your perfect flavor. For example, I usually get a chocolate milkshake and add peanut butter, which is a great combo! They also have dairy free milkshakes so that vegans and people with lactose intolerance don't have to miss out on the fun!