Burgatory has all the makings of a slick restaurant chain; build your own burger menu, stylized wall art (a la choose your own adventure journey chart), Buffalo Wild Wings inspired layout, and hipster artisan light bulbs. Like other burger places, heavy on the toppings and the bun is 3 sizes to big...but if you can find the meat, you'll be pleasantly surprised.
We visited Burgatory on a Saturday night at 6pm and ended up waiting 2 hours (literally), and our expectations were a little high.
I chose a burger off the menu while my boyfriend built his own so we could have a mix of things to try. I really wanted my meal to live up to expectations (and maybe my expectations were too high, coming from having many made-to-order burger joints to choose from in NYC).
Overall the quality is very good, but it just seems like everyone is enamored by the toppings; however the overall burger just didn't do it for me.