Almost 5 stars, but the service was spotty.
Ok our food was delicious from start to finish. As others have noted, the cheese curds are outstanding, not greasy like most places. The wings were also excellent, big and plump.
The burgers of course were fantastic, each of the 4 of us tried a different one and they were all great, not a morsel left by the end of the meal, and we were stuffed and happy.
Go here.