As a whole, four stars but if going for happy hour or a daily special then Shady Grove deserves six (yeah, I know the max is five)!
Shady Grove is a nice place right in the heart of Shadyside. They have a great happy hour with beer and wine selections along with daily food/drink specials. Let me recommend going on a Monday evening after 5pm. Happy hour runs from 5-7pm and burgers are half price after 5pm! It is such an amazing deal! Staff always seems kind and the specials truly can't be beat!
I love Shady Grove's happy hour so much that I included it in a blog: https://www.nataliezazula.com/adventure/2017/12/1/shadyside-happy-hours