I can't say I was surprised by my experience at Juliano's, since I think every town has a classic, family-owned restaurant. The reviews were good, but I'm having trouble figuring out why they were this good..
Food: I had the Sicilian pizza, and it was ok, but I didn't enjoy the flavor of the dough. It tasted like it had been frozen or something. My friend ordered the eggplant part, and it was probably 5lbs worth of food. It wasn't awful, but it offered nothing new. It was heavily breaded and soggy and under mounds of pasta. He also mentioned that it appeared the plate had been microwaved.
Atmosphere: traditional family restaurant. Hadn't been updated in years, but it's what you'd expect and is fine.
Overall, I wouldn't choose to go back unless someone else wanted. I wouldn't turn it down, just won't be on my short list.