Three stars because the food and beer list are really good, not four stars because all the seating is bar style seat yourself, which totally sucks when it's Ohio State weekend and there are 1 million age 50+ ohio state fans in town clogging up all the tables.
If you want to go to a crowded sports bar, go to Guido's so you can see people under the age of 65 and not have to drive all the fucking way out to Windsor and Duncan.