Came to Holy Chuck for a casual dinner with a friend, and had a very good experience.
I spent quite a while looking at the menu, but decided on grabbing the Village Bahahastard, which came "saganaki style", which is probably the fastest way to have me say yes to something. I also grabbed an order of fries with it. My friend ordered the Cowlorie, also with fries.
Our orders came relatively quick, but they come out and shout your name, so you better be paying attention. A mild annoyance.
Once in front of us, it really hits you just how big these burgers are. I had the smaller of two burgers, but it was still quite the mouth-stretcher in terms of height. Taste-wise, the lamb in the Village Bahahastard was great, as I am a huge fan of lamb, but if gaminess bothers you, you might want to look elsewhere. The Cowlorie was also quite tasty, and the grilled cheese buns were a nice little touch.
In general, the burgers were very tasty, however, were quite salty and quite greasy. It was a solid meal, but I felt like I had to drink an entire bottle of water afterward.
Overall, Holy Chuck was a solid meal, if on the saltier side, but I definitely want to come back and try more things on the menu.