The only thing holding them back from 5 stars is that their high staff turnovers results in inconsistent milkshake quality.
I love their ice cream and milk shakes. I have only tried some of the chocolate and whole excellent, the price is out of my regular spending range. Milkshake happy hours are where it's at: Wednesdays from 4-6 half price shakes, which is only just over $2!
Unfortunately my scoop fell off the cone once and they have me a whole new cone, no hassle. They will also make doggy ice cream bowls with vanilla ice cream and peanut butter.
It is one of my favorite throngs about living in south side.