I must have been here 7 or 8 times and luckily, I have never paid for any of those meals, so my review is not overrated because I overpaid.
However, I think I WOULD PAY for it myself to eat here (but I just haven't since I keep on getting freebies : )
I have never had a bad meal here. I obviously get steak here and it has been excellent every single time. I have had stone crabs most of the time.....and I just don't like them that much. I love crabs in general, but there is something about stone crabs that I'm not going to go out of my way and pay for it myself, but if you have never had one, then you should probalby try it. Their huge seafood platter with stone crabs, ceviche, prawns, lobsters are excellent especially the ceviche.
All in all, if you want consistantly good, solid steaks (especially their bone in fillet or bone in ribeye) then this is a good place.