I'll echo the other reviewers' sentiments and say this is an eclectic place for a gift. A gift for, perhaps, your landlady who just had a baby, your cousin who looooves kitschy, recycled jewelry or your sister in law who adores candles.
Green With Envy is a cool store to shop around in - but it will take you a little while. Not only is the store pretty sizeable, but it also is scattered with merchandise. Much of said merchandise is grouped together - art in the front corner, candles in the other front corner, jewelry in the middle, clothing near the back, baby gear near the back, and cards and more gifty stuff near the register. But, even though it's grouped together, you'll find quite the random selection of things! Even I, shopper extraordinaire, was a hair overwhelmed.
Regardless, I found a handful of things that were quite lovely. A few pairs of locally sourced earrings and some cute cards. To me, this shop is reminiscent of Paper Skyscraper with a bit more crammed in merchandise and an extra shot of estrogen. While I didn't make any purchases during this visit, next time I'm in need for a girly gift, Green With Envy is a go - as long as I have the time to sift through!