I know I'm jumping on the bandwagon here...but this place is awesome. I recently checked out the new location in Cleveland Heights and had an awesome time and an incredible meal. I was prepared for a long wait and was quoted 45 minutes by the hostess, but quickly found a seat at the bar, ordered a delicious drink, and was given a table just a short 10 minutes later! The service was fun and attentive and it was hilarious watching some of the sandwich creations that came out of the kitchen. I personally ordered the monthly special (some sort of delicious roast beef/horseradish/potato monstrosity) and have been craving it ever since -- hopefully they serve it again!
Go check out Melt with an open mind and some patience, and you'll have a great time.