There is a reason Mitchell's Ice Cream always makes the Beat of lists in Cleveland... It's because they truly are. Our family found Mitchell's via Scene Magazines Best Of and I am so very glad! We've pretty much stopped eating ice cream from anywhere else. We buy the take homes and stock the freezer every so often, otherwise we take a drive up from Warren and enjoy some!
I am very impressed at the consistency of their product. Many places who make their favors are not as consistent in the taste and texture and I fee this sets them leaps and bounds apart from the rest.
My Personal favorite is the Caramel Sea Salt. I love the rich creamy dark taste of it. I love a waffle cone of it.
Their ice cream toppings are also quite stellar. In Truth I have not had anything here that was not!
If you have not tried Mitchell's you really need to. It's worth every penny.