The good: fantastic ambience, very nice staff, great bar, and plenty of parking. The food is usually good, but consistency is a key, which brings me to the ....
Could-be-better: mixed results on food - sometimes comes out nice, other times bland, over-cooked and leaves a lot to be desired. To be fair, they have always been very considerate about it, and have offered to replace my order (even though I wouldn't ask for that). There is no reason why such a talented team won't nail it every single time.
Conclusion: a very nice restaurant if you want to get something a little bit fancy. Worth trying. I'll definitely come back for more, hoping this place will earn its reputation as the best restaurant in Urbana.