Hm Lucille is an interesting place - it tries to be upscale pizza, but the pizza really isn't THAT much better than some of the nearby competitors.
The reason I still give it 4 stars is the ambience, service, and location. The place is gorgeous! Huge high ceilings and lots of lighting and (oddly) club music. Makes for an interesting combination! They have a nice upper floor with great decor and lighting while the lower floor has the bar area and is always packed.
The restaurant generally gets quite crowded for dinner, so I would prepare for that. This is a pretty perfect place for a Friday night out with a group of friends though! I would really not recommend this for an intimate dinner, since the music is pretty loud and the bar area is generally fairly loud as well.
Now don't get me wrong, the pizza is quite good! Its more expensive than other pizza places, but the decor should have led you to that conclusion. If you're looking for truly good pizza, I would suggest Grampa's on Willy! Comparable prices (much longer wait usually), but much more intimate setting and very good pizza.