As a fan of the Village Idiot- it's sister next door, I figure I'd check out Sin & Redemption. The place has an extensive beer selection with a great beer menu that describes each beer, unique ingredients, percent and all. The service was fine and the prices were more than fair. The place lacks in character and was way too loud for a pub atmosphere. I'd go back for drinks but that's it. My recommendation is to head next door and enjoy they quaint, quirky atmosphere of the Village Idiot.