I give this place 5 stars simply because of the mac and cheese pizza.
The rest of the pizzas are good, but the reason why this place deserves a line out the door is the mac and cheese pizza.
At first it really weirded me out. In fact I didn't even order one and simply bummed bites from other people. Now that I have actually experienced the magic first hand, I will be making a return visit at some point in the future and will be sure to order the infamous mac and cheese pizza.
I hear this guy Ian, or someone he knows runs a pizza place in Minneapolis. Hopefully they have the mac and cheese pizza as well. But for some reason, I don't expect it to taste quite as good as it did in Madison. Wisconsin is the dairy state after all.