Milk Bar is located on the second floor of Cosmo, right in front of the escalators. Given that there was so much hype around their NY location, I was really excited to finally be able to try it for myself. ...I guess I'm glad I got to try it once?
The cereal milk ice cream was SO SO SO SO SO overrated. Even considering "strip prices," the amount you get for the price you pay is not worth it at all. I liked that the taste of the ice cream was subtle. I do not suggest the corn flake topping; I get that people add salt to bring out the flavors of desserts -- but this was wayyy too salty. We also got a corn cookie and compost cookie. The corn cookie tasted like corn bread in cookie form, which I surprisingly really enjoyed. Compost cookie had interesting texture to it (it has potato chips in it!).
In regards to the service, it was very subpar. They were quick to fulfill my order, but let's be real, you're just dispensing ice cream and handing me prepackaged cookies. The lady who took my order could not understand my order at all. I had to repeat my order several times and still she got it wrong.
TL;DR This place was way overhyped. The ice cream and corn cookie weren't bad, but given the price and service, I don't think I'll be coming back.