I've eaten here many times, mainly because we liked the restaurant prior to it becoming the Attic. I will admit the food is really good, the beers are great, and the decor is my style.
So why the two stars then?
The biggest problem this place has is customer service. It is poor, at best. The two times we have been there the staff were either rude or they ignored their tables. Very well could have been understaffed but it happened twice. This is a real shame because the food is excellent and I love the location. The only thing keeping me from coming back is the poor service I've experienced both times I've been there.