Full disclosure: we eat here every couple of months.
We ate here last Friday night for the fish fry. We consider this one of the 3 best places in Madison for fish on Friday and the reason is because it is so darn consistent. The serving portions are huge and the tartar sauce, coleslaw, etc. is alwayz the same. GREAT! So we both ordered the cod. My cutee patootee had an old fashioned (you forgot to muddle it) and I had a sidecar. Both delicious. A funny story about the sidecar....I asked the bartender if he knew how to make one and he said yes I do so I kept my eye on him and noticed he was misting my drink with the oils from the zest of the lemon. Uhhhh ya. They know what they're doing. LOL and as a side note, Marcia commented that I'm the only person she's ever see pick up the fish to eat it....ya....that's how we Colorado men roll....and we lick our fingers too. ;D Good eating everyone!