Yelp needs a "4.5 stars" option-- Heritage Tavern almost nailed it. Definitely among the best in Madison. Like most "fine dining" restaurants, I did not end up "stuffed" like I usually do after the meal (ok, that's probably a good thing, but I generally have a hell of an appetite...) Chef is famous for pork, so that's what I got and it was all awesome. Only thing that knocked it from a 5-star was one of the desserts (a chocolate cake-- forget the exact name) that would have been more at home on a buffet table at the Hilton than here (and it was ~$12 or so... this place ain't cheap). The other dessert (squash cake?) was great (but again, pricey). Definitely a special occasion type of place unless you are seriously loaded or someone else is picking up the tab!