I've eaten here before, it's nothing special but it's definitely a neighbourhood favourite.
I called to make a reservation and I was greeted with two things: 1) we don't take reservations (which is totally understandable), 2) "the next time you want to make a reservation for a restaurant, call a day in advance (which I found very obnoxious). I mean, this is a family pub with subpar food and most of the appeal is driven from the bar. For an employee to have the audacity to think that he can say that kind of crap, especially for a restaurant that's viewed as a casual neighbourhood spot, is extremely pretentious and shocking.
Good luck in the long run, I really enjoyed your grilled cheese