This is my absolute favorite place to get BBQ in Cleveland. Having gone to school in AL I have had my fair share BBQ and Proper Pig nails it every time. If you are going with another person I would suggest getting the platter and splitting so you can try a variety of the meats. My personal favorites are the brisket & smoked turkey. Their ribs come off the bone easily without falling off the bone, meaning they're not overcooked (which is rare to find a place who does it right)!
I also ordered catering for a company event and everyone RAVED about all the food, including the wings. They also started doing beef rib on Thursdays so add another thing to your list to try from this fabulous BBQ joint!!!!