The best bagels in Toronto, but make sure you get the fresh warm ones. My favorites are the grain based bagels. The chocolate is not as good as it sounds. You'll be happier with other sweet choices like blueberry and raisin. If you're not sure what you like remember to ask if they have tasters.
I've tasted every bagel, and found personally I enjoy the fresh taste over the type. I've had many taste tests. Just try and get the last thing out of the oven. I guarantee it will taste the best.
Even if they aren't the freshest batch they are still fresh, but not as amazing! Make sure to try a few different types, and also be sure to tell them exactly what you want. If you are not specific you might get a mix of bagels from the morning. These would be slightly less amazing.
From my experience even their day old bagels are better than most other bagels in Toronto. I would give them a 5 if they didn't give me those hard bagels that 1 time.