Good service, great hours, and pretty good food.
We tried oysters, shrimp, mussels, and the house beer.
Oysters were 6 for $12; somewhat expensive for Scarborough but fairly good.
Shrimp and mussels were quite good with varying sauces. Shrimp were not de-veined (I think that's the norm for these places, but for some people that's a deal breaker). The sauces weren't as good as Captain's Boil in my opinion, but still fairly flavourful and more than enough in quantity.
The $1 beer is about what you'd expect, but a welcome addition to any establishment that opens until 2am.
Overall,it's not quite as good as Captain' s Boil but it comes close. Especially for being this far north/east, it's an excellent option!