I went to Next Door for the first time this past week, and I really liked it. Nice decor and even though I was with a large group, service was efficient and friendly. I didn't order any food but I tried someone's fried cheese curds (obviously no match for the reining champ on the square, but that's a pretty high bar).
They have a lot of good house brews - I really like stouts and their eggnog stout was fantastic.