I would put this place at 3.5. This place's high points are it's great renovation. The inside of this place is awesome and homey. I could sit there for hours. I also love the use of local art to adorn the walls. This place just has a good feel about it.
The flip side is probably that they are a little pricey. This is bad considering some of the local shops that have better food and coffee at better prices. So, all in all, this place is a good little stop for some pretty good coffee and comfort.