First off, the service was impeccable. Friendly, personable, unpretentious...our server really took care of us. The drinks were good too. I had rusty nail - a drink that many restaurants seem to mess up, and it was bit on the sweet side but still good.
As for food we ordered the beef tartare, and I really enjoyed that. Everything else was just OK for me. The fois gras my girlfriend loved. Me? It was good. I don't seek it out, so I would take her opinion over mine. A steak that was decent, but not great. For dessert, we ordered the chocolate cake deal. I liked it - I'm a dessert person - but I wasn't blown away by it. It was the generic molten chocolate cake that most restaurants make.
Food overall? Meh. Good but stuffy fancy food done the same way it always is. Very little creativity.
Service? Excellent. You are definitely paying for the service over the food.
Decor and atmosphere? Generic fancy restaurant. Nice and quiet though.
Would I come back? I doubt it.
Would i recommend it? If you're meeting your significant other's parents for the first time, I might recommend this place. But probably not for any other situation.