This is generally a great place. Their pizza is the closest to real NYC pizza I've found. But you must try their calzones!!! So huge and so good. Their pizza would easily get 5+ stars from me (definitely worth giving it a try).
The people behind the cash register are always nice. Tony remembers many people by name, and often walks around and exchanges stories in the best spirit of Italian pizza places in New York.
Why would I give them only 3 stars then, you may ask... Mostly because this place is somewhat inconsistent. We have ordered garlic knots every time we came and they come out differently every single time. Sometimes you get 2 little containers of marinara sauce & sometimes just one. Sometimes your marinara is chunky and delicious and once in a while it's like thin tomato soup. I don't like the taste of water either, but that might be a personal preference but since I don't drink soda or sweetened iced teas, I sometimes feel stuck.
Overall, definitely check it out!!!