Solid restaurant, good service & atmosphere. Very family oriented.
Definitely order the Original Reuben Sandwich. The pumpernickel is slightly toasted, which gives the sandwich nice variety in texture. The Montreal Smoked Meat is DIVINE, as is the horseradish, and cheese that comes in it. Solid coleslaw, okay poutine.
I wouldn't order anything else, to be honest. If you're going to Reuben's, you're going there for the Smoked Meat.
Could definitely upgrade the atmosphere with a face lift - maybe have a little more light as it was very dark. Just a thought :)