Slice House did a great job renovating the space which was home to Lupie's for years. A nice needed change for the downtown strip. I will preface my review by stating this is mainly about our experience dining in. We have yet to order to-go.
Pizza by the slice is overpriced. The quality is decent enough but not for nearly $4 a slice. We aren't talking NY size slices. Flavors are decent and ingredients seem to be quality, but our pizza was served sort of lukewarm after supposedly running through the oven for reheating. Salad was delicious and the balsamic dressing was great. However, for 4 slices of pizza, two side salads, and two drinks I felt robbed for paying close to $30. The pricing is heavily skewed toward buying a whole pizza...which makes sense from a business perspective given how expensive the seating space rent probably runs. Service was good, but execution of reheating slices could be better.
I would just recommend that if you're going with anyone other than yourself you just buy a whole pie so you pay less and and product is fresh and hot!