I've been here a couple times after being introduced via the YEE because Good Catch Boil exceeded my expectations and had lasting first impressions!
The place is a comfortable place to lounge in and the ceilings are high. Also a lot of TV's playing sports games along the wall, including one with 9 screens on it. :oo
I like their new lunch special a lot. It's mess-free and all their seafood is fresh. It's hard to believe, but my favourite items here are anything that has raw vegetables in it; or any of the salad options.
I like the poke (~$11-13), mainly for the salad components. Don't expect a heap of fish in the bowl though. They have the jumbo fish roe as well, but only about 6 pieces. Aside from that, all the veggies are super good. I even like the taste of the tuna in their tuna poke. Also, the tofu skins (which i regularly wouldn't order) and crispy taro crisps in their veggie poke were delish. My favourite poke is their salmon with either the sushi rice or zoodles and grapefruit sauce.
Their wings basket (~$7/6pcs or ~$13/12pcs) are SUPERB! A must-order. They're meaty and both sauce options (buffalo and honey-garlic) are delicious. Comes with cajun fries , which are SO good, they're like those crunchy & fluffy costco fries but with cajun spice powdered over top. *_*
I like their beer selection. It's served on tap which is extremely rare in Markham! Really like their Waterloo Grapefruit Raddler. Tastes like juice :P
I'd skip out on the Lobster Supreme Fries ($10 via Yelp checkin til June 30). Although there are lobster pieces in there they're quite small, and they're served over a different type of fries (soggy oven-baked fries instead of the cajun fries)