We came to District to see the Nutcracker at 7:00. We arrived at 5:40 and both ordered steak. I ordered medium-rare, and my girlfriend ordered medium. My NY Strip came out medium well, and my girlfriend's Delmonico came out rare. Not only that, but her steak was 3/4 fat and the "roasted" potatoes were gritty, flavourless, and tasted microwaved.
Our waitress came by and noticed how rare the steak was, so she took it back and said she'd be back soon with a new one. It ended up taking half an hour or more for the fresh steak to come out, at which point I'd already finished my meal.
When the new steak came out, it too was an inedible lump of fat and gristle (see picture). Overall, the Delmonico meal was inedible and disgusting. The only edible part was the chimichurri sauce. The NY Strip was decent.
The wait staff was friendly and apologetic, but the food was poorly prepared and slow to arrive. The staff was nice enough to reduce the bill from $65 to $31.