My girlfriend and I went to CIP 10/16/09. First I want to say that we had great service. our waitress was always there when we needed something and always brought it to us in a few seconds.
I don't know how people can say this pizza is anything special or how it can be "the best pizza in the valley" because its not, especially for $13 for a 12inch pepperoni. Let me put it this way $13 for pizza, $26 for their cheapest bottle of wine, $7 for an appetizer add tax and its almost $50 for two people. Now the pizza, the crust taste about the same as Tonys, yeah Tonys the $1 pizza from the freezer section at frys. The toppings where great cheese was nice and melted, great flavor and the pepperoni was a little sweet.
the interior would look better if:
1. Put a simple white table cloth on the table.
2. Get new chairs, that arn't from IKEA. one thing that really bugged me is that the tables where a darker color and the chairs where a brighter kind of yellowish color. Even if they took my first suggestion it wouldn't matter because the chairs are from IKEA.
other than that the interior was pretty cool, o except the soccer ball and trophy on top of the wine cabinet, which was kind of out of place with everything else.
I wouldn't go back unless the dropped the price, increace the size of the pizza (and not the cost) and fixed the interior things that bugged me.