I'm a big fan of Gimme Java Coffee! A place like this was sorely needed in the neighborhood. It is neighbor to Simply Delicious Pies, another favorite of mine.
The interior is well decorated, cozy with a fire, and the service is the friendliest around. The owners will remember your name if they can and you can tell that they are trying their absolute best to give you the best experience.
My only request is there be a written list, somewhere, anywhere!, of the loose-leaf tea selections. When I ordered a tea I had to smell all of the canisters to figure out which I wanted. Not an unpleasant experience but a list would be easier.
From what I hear as a non-coffee drinker, the cups of joe are good. I've eaten lunch and breakfast there a couple of times and have really enjoyed the sandwiches, which are made to order and somewhat customizable.
5 stars for Gimme Java! I also love the name--my boyfriend goes there most days and we have a joke that he walks in and says "GIMME JAVA!" while shaking his fist. I'm not with him for his coffee run most mornings but I like to believe this is true, and it makes me smile.