As a recent Madison transplant, this was the first stop in my neighborhood after hearing rave reviews. It's worth the hype. Split a pizza (can't remember the name but had spicy giardinera veggies on top), calamari & a Caesar salad with my dinner companion. Calamari might be some of the best I've ever had... no grease, crispy panko breading. Great service, beautiful atmosphere, very pleased this is within walking distance as I will make many return visits!