Very badly disorganized. Called Rectory today, confirmed what time they were closing. We Arrived today at 3:45pm knowing the kitchen closes in 45 minutes, first massively nice day at the island this year, we got in a line for a table. We were 8th person in line. Servers told us to be patient they were cleaning tables (plenty looked available). We waited 30 minutes in line before someone actually told the whole line that they were shutting the whole kitchen down at 4:30pm and basically they would only serve 4 more people at the front of the line, they literally didn't want to seat people who had waited in line for 30 minutes beside the fact the kitchen was open for a while.?!?! Why could no staff member have told us that while they say us waiting in line for so long? Eventually like 20 people were in line. shutting down early they turned away a ton of people. I go to Toronto Islands all time and have never ate at the Rectory but have heard such bad reviews of bad, slow service and ridiculously overpriced food and well...now I get it to. Won't bother trying to go back.