The Carlton is one of those places that feels as if it's from a different time - in a good way.
When every single restaurant in the city was booked at 6pm on a Saturday night, my party of four had no issue getting into The Carlton to celebrate my mom's birthday. Between us, we ordered two Prime Rib dinners, a Walleye Pike and the Sea Bass special. Every single bite was near-perfection. Between drinks, apps, entrees our total bill rang in at ~$220; not too shabby all things considered. I think it's silly when restaurants of this caliber charge per the glass for sodas, but I'll let that one go.
So, throw on a fedora and stop in at The Carlton to experience old-fashioned food and service sure to leave even the most jaded hipster with a smile of satisfaction.