Went here for a post-dinner dessert after seeing ti was one of the top 10 attractions in Old Town (according to one of the newspaper clippings attached to a signpost). It was just okay. Got a banana split and although it wasn't bad, it wasn't worth going out of my way for. I personally think that it's so popular based on the nostalgia factor of people remembering coming here as kids. If you've got some time to kill and want ice cream, this is a nice little shop. But by no means would I say it's worth going out of your way to come here like I did.