Smallman's is a great, casual place to go with a large variety of things to choose from. I haven't had any dinner type meals there, but their breakfast food and sandwiches are great. You also get a lot of food for the money. Most times I try to get something new, but if I'm ever unsure, the Reuben is the way to go. Without a doubt one of the best Reubens around.
And when you walk into Smallman's you could easily be going back to the 50s or 60s, where you feel like part of a community and everyone knows this is the place to eat. There's always plenty of seating, inside or out. Whenever it's nice, the patio is the place to sit and watch the people walk by on Murray Avenue.
The staff there is always friendly and they make you feel welcome the minute you walk in.