My review is almost exactly the same as Avitania B.'s review on 2/19/10. I think we may have eaten the exact same night, we were there on the 19th as well around 9:00pm. We ordered the EXACT same items. My girlfriend had the Mac & Cheese with Bacon and I ordered the Cheese Burger and salad with wax paper wrapped french fries in a soup can. Tasty, but as Avitania B. wrote, it was not worth raving about. I gave it a solid good.
As we arrived in Montreal late - driving in from Quebec City. We asked our hotel concierge [W Hotel] what they recommended in the area that was open late and affordable - a Montreal feel - which we specifically wanted cheap. I expected a downtown location would not have cheap/dive type, so above cheap is what I expected. But, $17 Mac & Cheese was a bit over priced. The Mac & Cheese could have had something to go with it at least at that price.
Our food was better than average and it was a little better than we expected at 9pm. We did not leave loving it or hating it. We were just happy.