I've been here twice. The first time was a "5". The last time was a "3". So for now I'm giving it a 4.
We ordered two dishes. One pizza which was excellent and one pasta dish which was horrible. If you get some crappy dry pasta at Harris Teeter, dump some store bought tomato sauce on it, you then would have the dish that we were served. It sucked.
The service was horrific. Our initial server appeared to have Ogre DNA. I say that from both an aesthetic standpoint and from an intellectual point of view. We waited and waited. Then he asked "Are you ready to order?". We enthusiastically said "Yes!" as we had been waiting for a while. He then walked away and after another 10 minutes passed I asked for a different server who was very good. It's not as though the place was busy with it being after 9PM at this point.
It's too bad. I really liked this place a lot initially. But now I won't be rushing back.