Came here after doing a bit of shopping. Being a New Yorker, I decided to see how other places did their pizza, so...in comes CiCi's.
Service: Friendly enough. But the staff stand around for the most part.
Atmosphere: Typical buffet restaurant. Quite popular with locals.
Food: Meh- but incredibly cheap! While the buffet itself (filled with an unlimited pizza and salad bar) is $5.99, you can get an individual slice for 81 cents. Yes, 81 cents. The slices are really small and not that remarkable, but you get what you pay for.
I bought the pepperoni stuffed crust and the garlic veggie slices. The former was really doughy, had a sauce that was reminiscent of ketchup and was doused with too much butter, but did the trick. I liked the garlic veggie slice, but unfortunately the crust was so thin it reminded me of water crackers.
CiCi's pizza would have normally received two stars for the quality and taste of food- it isn't bad, but I've had WAY better pizza. However, they get an extra star due to its incredible value and generosity of food offerings.