I got a cookie cup for $6.50 plus paid an extra $1 for a toasted marshmallow.
Fatty Daddy pretty much has your standard flavors for ice cream and macarons; nothing too unique or exotic. For the ice cream, they were close to selling out of nutella; not enough to make a cup but I still sampled it and thought it was good.
They were sold out of the caramel macaron and I didn't want vanilla or strawberry. I'm not a fan of coconut and I know fruity pebbles is trendy, but I was never fan of it, either. My only option left was red velvet.
Salted caramel is usually one of my go-to's so I didn't even think about sampling it first. I thought it should go well with the red velvet macaron, so I went with it. Off course I had to add a toasted marshmallow for extra effect.
I liked the concept of the cookie cup and appreciate what they're trying to do. It was just way too sweet for me...and I have a huge sweet tooth. The salted caramel ice cream didn't even taste good. It was a disappointment, especially for how much it costs. I say if you're doing it for the 'gram, go for it, but don't expect to be blown away.
I do have to say though that the person there was very friendly and the other flavors we did try were pretty tasty.