Update: Five Stars. I'm really struggling to remember why I ever gave them four instead of five.
Nonetheless -- since my original reviews, I've ordered from JVG (as I like to abbreviate them) four or five times. We've tried a selection of their specialty fries and sandwiches and have NEVER been disappointed. Tonight I ordered their March Madness special (as listed on their Facebook page) and was so happy. We got a philly cheesesteak sandwich, the chicken ranch fries, fried mushrooms, and a 2L of diet coke. It was more than enough to feed the two of us with some leftovers to spare.
We've only ever done delivery, largely because it's consistent and delicious. My husband feels like he has a "relationship" with the driver at this point, which is a sign of a good local business. The food is great - we've tried a pretty broad selection and have never had complaints. It always comes hot and fresh, and reheats pretty well (see my below hash suggestion). We will certainly continue to order from the JVG. :)