This was my first visit to a Dave's Cosmic Subs. I had a Super Dave, and it was absolutely the best sub I've ever had! The coleslaw was amazing. I would totally go back just to get a side of the slaw. I really loved the texture of the bread - it was sturdy and chewy (not soft and wimpy like Subway), but not crispy/flakey either. And I also really liked the Dave's cosmic sauce, which was similar to Italian dressing. I really appreciated the way the sandwich was assembled - bread, then sauces, then lettuce/tomato, then meat, then slaw. I liked that there were flavorful things both on top and beneath the meat, and I always prefer when the sauces are adjacent to both bread and lettuce. Another huge plus for me was the birch beer in the soda fountain. An unexpected opportunity to try something new is always great for me!
I typically only give 5 stars to places that are consistently excellent, but I didn't think it was fair to knock off a star simply because I've only been here once. I have nothing to complain about, and my experience was far better than I had expected.