My girlfriend and I ate at Donatello in August of 2014. This restaurant has stood out in my mind so greatly that I still felt compelled to write a review almost 1 year later.
The atmosphere was romantic. Each staff member was friendly. The food. Oh man, the food was out of this world. I wouldn't say I am the authority on Italian, but Donatello cooked the best Italian food I have ever had the pleasure of eating. We ate a bruschetta for starters which was delicious. My girlfriend had a pesto pasta that she loved, I had some sort of pasta in a cream sauce with mushrooms, and it was delicious. You can tell that almost everything (if not everything) is homemade from scratch every day.
I ate too much, as I am prone to doing, but everything was sooo good, that I had to have dessert. We went with tiramisu. I have had a number of tiramisus before, and I am often left feeling less than amazed by them. This one ranked in the top 3 tiramisus I have had, so very good.